Philosophers have asserted for centuries that A and Not-A cannot both be true at the same time. For example, a small domestic animal cannot be both a cat and not a cat simultaneously. The Trump Administration, however, apparently believes this law of non-contradiction does not apply to its trade policy.
In a letter to the Wall Street Journal (Nov. 16, 2026, print edition), U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer brags that U.S. consumers pay only a fraction of the cost of tariffs. He cites Morningstar economist, Preston Caldwell, for this claim. Of course, if the claim is true, then it would set aside all conclusions about tariffs found in economic history. Indeed, historically, one of the principal purposes of tariff policies has been to protect domestic industries from foreign competition by raising the prices of otherwise cheaper imports.
What is particularly interesting in Mr. Greer’s claim is that it is contrary to what President Trump asserted during his 2024 presidential campaign and during his time in office, claiming that cheaper imports are often, if not mostly, the result of foreign subsidies and other such “rip offs” by foreign governments. Tariffs are therefore necessary to equalize the playing field within U.S. markets.
Mr. Greer and Mr. Trump thus seem to be at odds about the economic effects of tariffs. To make this point I submitted a letter to the Journal responding to Mr. Greer. That letter was published in today’s print edition (Nov. 18, 2026). The digital link is here. For those readers unable to get past the paywall, I copy the text of the letter below.
———————————————————————–
The Broken Promises Behind Trump’s Tariffs
Which administration position am I supposed to believe?
After reading U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer’s letter, I’m scratching my head as to what the Trump administration believes the effects of tariffs are (“The Success of President Trump’s Trade Policy,” Nov. 16). The president says that tariffs are a tool in the effort to revitalize U.S. manufacturing. They do so by protecting U.S. firms from the competition of cheaper imports. Adding tariffs to the price of imports makes U.S. manufactured products more competitive within U.S. markets, and consumers can be expected to reallocate their expenditures accordingly.
But Mr. Greer says that only a fraction of the cost of tariffs is passed on to consumers. If so, why would consumers shift more purchases to American-made products, and how is U.S. manufacturing helped? Mr. Greer is making a claim irreconcilable with that of his boss. Which administration position am I supposed to believe?
Theodore A. Gebhard
Mr. Gebhard was a senior economist with the International Trade Administration.